BLOG
A Court Judgment Does Not Expire in Sixty Days
The administration collected money from you; a court then annulled the basis of that collection. How long do you have to ask for the excess back? Sixty days, two years or ten years?
By its decision of 6 October 2026, E. 2026/2541, K. 2026/1814, the 3rd Administrative Chamber of the Diyarbakır Regional Administrative Court set aside the first instance judgment that had answered "sixty days". The decision is final; the file has gone back to the court of first instance for examination on the merits.
A Thirteen-Year-Old Fine; Paid, Refunded, Collected Again
The story begins in 2012. The Competition Board imposes an administrative fine of roughly TRY 2.9 million on a company. Relying on the early payment discount in Article 17 of the Law on Misdemeanours, the company pays three quarters of the fine and files an action. When the administrative court annuls the fine, the amount paid is refunded to the company.
In 2019 the Council of State reverses the annulment; the fine comes back to life. This time the administration demands the full amount through a payment order. The company challenges the payment order in court and pays the amount demanded under reservation. The payment order is annulled, and that judgment becomes final in 2025 after review by the Council of State. In the same year, the action against the fine itself is finally decided against the company.
What remains is this calculation. In 2012 the company had used its right to pay at a discount; by the end of the process it had paid the fine in full. On 3 October 2025 it asked the tax office to refund the difference of roughly TRY 725 thousand with interest. When no reply came, it went to court.
The First Instance Said Sixty Days; the Appeal Court Looked at Limitation
The administrative court dismissed the action as out of time. According to its reasoning, the company had learned of the excess collection at the latest on 23 June 2025, when the last judgment was served; it should have filed an action or applied to the administration within sixty days. An application made after that period could not revive the time limit for bringing an action.
The Regional Administrative Court looked at the dispute from a different angle. There was a payment order annulled by a court and a sum collected on the basis of that payment order. The payment, having lost its basis, remained in the administration's assets without cause. The Chamber treated the matter as one of implementing a court judgment and applied by analogy Articles 77 and 82 of the Turkish Code of Obligations on unjust enrichment. The refund claim could be raised within two years of learning of it and in any event within ten years. Since the company applied to the administration a little over three months later, the action was in time.
The Outcome Is Sound; There Is a Gap in the Reasoning
I agree with the outcome. The time limit for bringing an action exists to protect administrative stability; there is no stability worth protecting in money retained despite a final court judgment. Article 138 of the Constitution obliges the administration to comply with court decisions and not to delay their execution. Article 28 of the Law on Administrative Judicial Procedure likewise requires the administration to do what the judgment calls for within thirty days at the latest. Since this duty does not depend on an application by the person concerned, a late application cannot release the administration from its debt.
Under Law No. 6183 the administration can pursue its own receivable for five years. Is a person who asks for the return of a collection whose basis has collapsed by court judgment to be given sixty days?
I do see a gap in the reasoning, however. The Chamber first says that the general limitation period applies to claims arising from the implementation of court judgments; it then applies the two-year period specific to unjust enrichment. The Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State, in its decision of 2 June 2011, E. 2011/217, K. 2011/616, had relied on the ten-year general limitation period for the retroactive monetary consequences of an annulment judgment. In this case the difference does not change the result. For someone who applies in the third year, however, the fate of the action will depend on which approach is adopted. A rule on time limits must be foreseeable; otherwise the right of access to a court is left at the mercy of diverging case law.
One more procedural note. In private law, limitation is a defence; in administrative justice, time limits are examined by the court of its own motion. What follows from the decision is this; the limitation period is the time allowed for applying to the administration, and after a refusal the sixty-day time limit for bringing an action still runs. Practitioners should not confuse the two.
The merits, meanwhile, remain open. The court of first instance will now answer the real question. Does a person who paid the fine on time and at a discount, and who got that money back thanks to an annulment judgment in their favour, lose the discount once that judgment is reversed? The Law on Misdemeanours states that early payment does not affect the right to seek judicial review. In my view, the price of going to court should not be the loss of the discount. As for interest, the Constitutional Court's approach, which I discussed on this page last week, is clear; an unlawful collection cannot be refunded without interest.
A court judgment does not expire in sixty days. An administration that must give back what it took cannot hide behind the calendar.
Source; decision of the 3rd Administrative Chamber of the Diyarbakır Regional Administrative Court dated 06.10.2026, E. 2026/2541, K. 2026/1814.
- Special Principles Are Gone, the List Remains; the Court Asked for a Legal Basis
- The Tax Debtors List; Transparency or Public Shaming?
- A Wrongly Collected Tax Cannot Be Refunded Without Interest
- The Report Lost in the Archive, the Penalty Imposed on the Taxpayer
- A Loss in the Fund Crisis Is Not a Single Legal Event
- The Chamber of Commerce Has an Accountants’ Committee; Why Is There No Lawyers’ Committee?
- The Provision in Article 359 of the Tax Procedure Law Is Not “Effective Remorse”
- Payment-Based Reduction in Tax Evasion and the Problem of the Remaining 50 Percent
- The Truth Behind the Haggling for Cash; the Card Commission
- What “No Amnesty, Only Instalments” Means on the Ground