BLOG
The Employer Holds the Key to the Corporate Inbox, the Law Sets the Limit
Who owns the corporate e-mail account assigned to an employee? The server belongs to the employer, the domain belongs to the employer, and the employer pays for the licence. Starting from there, many employers assume they may read everything inside the account whenever they wish. With its principle decision dated 16.09.2026 and numbered 2026/2035, the Personal Data Protection Board drew a clear line under that assumption. The decision was published in the Official Gazette of 08.10.2026; more than a month has passed, yet it is still not discussed enough in practice.
The decision begins with a simple observation. The fact that a corporate account belongs to the employer does not give the employer unlimited authority to monitor the personal data processed through that account. The Board treats even the review of traffic and log records alone as a personal data processing activity. Consequently, the general principles in Article 4 of the Law, the processing conditions in Articles 5 and 6, the duty to inform in Article 10 and the data security measures in Article 12 also apply to employers who say "it is our system anyway".
In my view the most important aspect of the decision is its stance on explicit consent. There is an imbalance of power between employee and employer in the employment relationship; it is hard to say that a consent form signed at recruitment rests on free will. For that reason the Board does not, as a rule, treat explicit consent as the primary legal basis; it directs the employer towards the other processing conditions, such as compliance with a legal obligation and legitimate interest, and towards the proportionality test that goes with them. The era in which every form of monitoring was legitimised simply because consent had been obtained is over.
The second important point is the duty to inform. A general sentence in the employment contract or an internal directive, along the lines of "corporate accounts may be monitored", is not considered sufficient. The employee must be told in advance and in clear terms on what legal basis, for what purpose and to what extent monitoring will be carried out; whether the review will be limited to traffic data or extend to content; in which cases content will be accessed and for how long the data will be retained.
The third point is gradation. The Board requires that the less intrusive method be preferred first. A content review requires a concrete suspicion or a legitimate purpose connected to a specific incident; the review must also be confined to that incident and to a defined period of time. Tools that continuously and indiscriminately scan the correspondence of all employees and record every action are considered disproportionate. Even where private use has been prohibited, the outcome does not change; where business and private correspondence cannot be separated, the employer's authority is interpreted narrowly.
The decision also contains clear sentences on the accounts of departing employees and on personal accounts. The account of an employee who has left must be closed to active use, forwarding and archiving must be limited and time-bound, and data that no longer has a legal basis must be destroyed. Being technically able to access an employee's personal e-mail and messaging accounts through a company device does not amount to legal authority to access them.
This approach is hardly new for Türkiye; what is new is that an administrative authority has turned it into a general principle decision. In its judgment of 17.09.2020 (Application No. 2016/13010), the Plenary of the Constitutional Court held that reading an employee's corporate e-mails without prior notice and terminating the employment contract on that basis violated the right to respect for private life and the freedom of communication. The Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights, in its 2017 judgment in Bărbulescu v. Romania, tied the employer's monitoring authority to criteria such as prior notice, the extent of the interference, legitimate reasons, the availability of less intrusive methods and procedural safeguards. The Board's decision is in the nature of a practical guide that brings this case law down to the daily routine of the workplace.
So what will change in practice? First of all, IT policies that record everything "to avoid any misunderstanding" must be reviewed. Data loss prevention systems and e-mail archiving solutions are not specifically regulated in the decision; however, the alerts and records they generate are also personal data processing activities and are subject to the same principles. Access authority must be concentrated in a small number of people, every access must be logged, and those with access must be bound by confidentiality. Where these steps are not taken, the administrative fines in Article 18 of the Law come into play; moreover, e-mail content obtained unlawfully also creates problems as evidence in an employment lawsuit.
We know this from tax audits; not every piece of data that is technically accessible has to be legally usable. The same principle applies in the workplace. The key to the server may stay with the employer; which door that key may open, and when, is for the Law to say.
This article is based on the Personal Data Protection Board's Principle Decision dated 16.09.2026 and numbered 2026/2035 (Official Gazette dated 08.10.2026, No. 33394), the Constitutional Court's judgment in Application No. 2016/13010 and the Grand Chamber judgment of the European Court of Human Rights in Bărbulescu v. Romania (61496/08).
- A Court Judgment Does Not Expire in Sixty Days
- Special Principles Are Gone, the List Remains; the Court Asked for a Legal Basis
- The Tax Debtors List; Transparency or Public Shaming?
- A Wrongly Collected Tax Cannot Be Refunded Without Interest
- The Report Lost in the Archive, the Penalty Imposed on the Taxpayer
- A Loss in the Fund Crisis Is Not a Single Legal Event
- The Chamber of Commerce Has an Accountants’ Committee; Why Is There No Lawyers’ Committee?
- The Provision in Article 359 of the Tax Procedure Law Is Not “Effective Remorse”
- Payment-Based Reduction in Tax Evasion and the Problem of the Remaining 50 Percent
- The Truth Behind the Haggling for Cash; the Card Commission